News

The latest on everything that matters to student life, from UCD’s campuses and from around the country

Otwo

The University Observer’s award-winning arts and culture supplement features the best in new music, film and fashion

Features

Peek behind the scenes of student life and gain a deeper insight into the matters shaping academic life

Science & Health

Thoughts, debate and commentary on the latest breakthroughs and discoveries about the wider world

Sport

Catch up with the latest UCD sports news and read opinion, debate and analysis on all things athletic

Home » News Analysis

Love UCD, Hate Racism

Contributed by Bridget Fitzsimons on Tuesday, 27 October 20094 Comments

In light of recent racist attacks on a UCD student, Bridget Fitzsimons asks why Ireland’s attitude to non-nationals has not changed

It is a sad fact that Ireland has not been known for its tolerant attitude in recent times. While we claim to be open to new peoples and ideas, especially in the academic world, the marked increase in the number of racially motivated attacks completely nullifies this claim.

The fact that an international PhD student currently studying at UCD – and their family – have been subject to this sort of attack should be enough to wake us up to the problems in society, but it does not seem to be doing anything of the sort. We seem content to look the other way, when in all honesty such casual disregard is far from good enough.

The most distressing part about our attitude to attacks on our neighbours is that we have all become immune to its tragedy. Racially motivated violence has become everyday in our society. We hear news reports, see devastating images in the media, but we never feel motivated to speak out against such prejudice.

Attacks focused on members of the academic community are not exclusive to UCD. A maths lecturer in Trinity College Dublin, Dr Calin Lazaroiu, who is originally from Romania, was attacked twice in less than 48 hours in Dublin. The first attack on Dr Lazaroiu left the lecturer with a fractured skull and a broken nose. Sickeningly, the second attack occurred as he was leaving a doctor’s surgery where he was treated in the aftermath of his first beating.

Dr Lazaroiu has stated that “my only crime was to come to Ireland to educate people,” and has admitted that further violence will drive him to leave the country. No one can blame someone like him for wanting to leave Ireland: why should well-educated people come to a country where they will be physically attacked and verbally ridiculed?

Respect seems to be lacking in Ireland at the moment – and coupled with our society’s obvious apathy to their welfare, the probability is that racially motivated attacks like this will continue as long as we choose not to stand up and do something about it.

To its undoubted credit, UCD’s Graduate School of the College of Human Sciences has elected to be proactive. The school’s director, Professor Ben Tonra, took the attacks on his PhD student as an incentive to take positive action. A response group has been set up within the school, and members of staff – as well as graduate students – are pooling ideas and resources in an effort to ensure that incidents like this are kept to a minimum.

Such efforts are wholly necessary if Ireland’s reputation as a land of céad míle fáilte is not to be forever tarnished to the eyes of the rest of the world. What educated person, in their right mind, would come to a country that they know will only greet them with violence and abuse? We need to change both our attitudes and our actions in this regard – we must use our voices to show that we are opposed to these kinds of attacks, and will stand up for those who are victimised by them.

Universities, in particular, have their part to play in this. One of the biggest things a university like ours can benefit from is diversity. This diversity stems from having a student and staff populace who have been educated in a variety of different institutions, and who can bring a variety of different ideas to the proverbial table.

We cannot allow ourselves to become educationally stultified. In allowing a culture of fear to exist around non-nationals living in Ireland, we deny ourselves the chance to benefit from the wealth of knowledge that people have to offer.

We are lucky that the student in question has refused to allow this cowardly intimidation to stop them from completing their studies in UCD, but not all would be so brave. It is up to us, as an academic institution, to ensure that students and staff who come from abroad feel secure and safe in working and studying here. All we can do is make our voices heard and stand up for decency, morality and respect. There is no point in welcoming people who will not feel safe here.

We must also remember that Ireland is a nation of emigrants. We have a long history of leaving this island to set up roots somewhere new. Countries like the United States and Australia are home to millions who claim Irish ancestry. With such a history and international diaspora, it is hypocritical for us to treat non-nationals so terribly here at home. Perhaps we should look at all the people across the ocean who proudly call themselves Irish-American, and realise that there really is nothing but good to be gained from a tolerant, multicultural society.

4 Comments »

  • Colin Sweetman said:

    I think Ireland’s attitude towards racism has changed.

    Just not necessarily the few unwashed…

  • Mike said:

    Ummm can you present some proof that this lecturer was attacked based on racial grounds? Were the attackers black?

    To say this article is sensationalist multi-cult rubbish is an under statement.. but well done anyway, you will have a great future in the mainstream media.. things like evidence and objectivity aren’t valued much in that setting.

  • Pat Brady said:

    Why would the irish view change!
    The majority of parents in this country have zenophobia
    engraved in their psychie, and essentially feed such nonsense
    to their kids psychies also!
    You got to recogonise though, this is part of a much bigger problem,
    the bigger problem being how people live their lives, and what they do in their lives.
    There are far to many people in this country who, lets say, they have worked one job for in excess of 10 years, and become closed off to all else and feel that, however miserable and cringeworthy such job is, the feeling always becomes that they are the only ones doing anything meaningful. When they meet a few buddies in similar
    redicilious situation giving credence to their own plight the pretentiousness snowballs and we end up with the bigoted society we see today!
    People, too lazy to exercise properly, cynics who bully, and who cant understand anything outside their bounded existance…

    Anyway I have said enough….

  • Bridget Fitzsimons, News Editor said:

    Mike, the attack on Dr Lazariou was reported on in TCD’s college newspaper Trinity News. The attackers told him that he should “get out of here, or we’re going to kill you”. I think that given the fact that Dr Lazariou is Romanian and that he was attacked twice in similar circumstances in 48 hours is pretty substantial proof that the attacks were racially motivated.
    As for the UCD student, we wished to protect their identity, which I think is understandable given the nature of the attacks and the fact that the student has a family.
    I think that the fact that you have called my article “sensationalist multi-cult rubbish” proves that Irish society has a long way to go before non-nationals will feel welcome here. As I state above, Ireland has always been a nation of emigrants, so it’s a bit rich that we react this way when people decide to come and make a life here, especially academics, who are really doing their part in enriching society and educating Irish citizens.
    You are a representation of a small minority who doesn’t think that multi-culturalism is a good thing. I think that your viewpoint is a sad one to have and hope that the Irish public stand up against people like you to make sure that we can begin to build a richer and more diverse society. Your views are stuck in the past and hopefully, with time, they will die and stay there, because there is no place for such ignorance in modern society.
    I would also like to call attention to the fact that this is a news focus piece and that I am completely entitled to put forward my own opinion in it. Whatever your thoughts on the piece may be, you cannot call into question its objectivity, as any parts of it that are not my opinion have been carefully researched by myself.